Comparison: Repair or replace a windshield, what to choose?

When a windshield is damaged, it is important to determine whether it should be repaired or replaced. The choice depends on several factors, including the size and location of the impact, as well as the overall condition of the windshield. Here is a comparison to help you make the right choice.

1. When to Opt for Windshield Repair?

Windshield repair is a quick and less expensive option, ideal for minor damage. It is generally recommended when the impact is minimal and does not compromise the safety of the vehicle.

Conditions for repair:

  • Impact size : The impact should not exceed 2 to 3 cm in diameter.
  • Location : If the impact is outside the driver's field of vision, repair is possible.
  • Number of impacts : Generally, if the windshield has only one impact, repair is possible.

Benefits of repair:

  • Saves time and money : Repair is less expensive than replacement and is done quickly (usually in less than 30 minutes).
  • Environmentally friendly : The repair minimizes waste by avoiding replacing the entire windshield.

2. When to Opt for Windshield Replacement?

Replacement is necessary when the windshield is too damaged to be repaired. If the cracks or impacts are too severe, replacement ensures the safety of the vehicle and its passengers.

Conditions for a replacement:

  • Impact size : If the crack exceeds 30 cm, the windshield must be replaced.
  • Location : If the impact is within the driver's field of vision, repair is not recommended as it may impair visibility.
  • Multiple impacts : If the windshield has multiple cracks or chips, replacement is often the best option.

Advantages of replacement:

  • Enhanced safety : A new windshield provides better resistance in the event of an accident.
  • Quality of vision : A replacement eliminates any visual discomfort caused by impacts or cracks, thus ensuring optimal vision.

3. What are the Costs Associated with Repair and Replacement?

The cost of repair is usually much lower than the cost of replacement. In fact, a repair often costs between 50 and 100 euros, while a replacement can vary between 300 and 600 euros, depending on the model of the vehicle and the type of windshield.

Cost of repair:

  • Varies depending on the extent of impact and location, but remains on average three times cheaper than replacement.

Cost of replacement:

  • The price depends on the vehicle model, the type of windshield (heated windshield, with rain sensor, etc.), and the services offered (such as warranties).

4. Insurance Coverage

In most cases, car insurance includes a "windshield breakage" guarantee that covers both the repair and replacement of the windshield. However, it is important to check the details of your contract, particularly regarding the excess.

What does the insurance cover?

  • Repair : Most insurers will cover repairs without applying a deductible, especially if you have taken out comprehensive insurance.
  • Replacement : Depending on the contract, there may be a deductible to pay for the replacement of the windshield, generally between 50 and 100 euros.

5. Durability: Which Solution is Most Reliable?

While repair can be a quick and cost-effective solution, it is not always as durable as a replacement. Even after repair, cracks can reappear if the windshield is subjected to additional impacts or extreme weather conditions.

Durability of repair:

  • It is generally effective for small impacts, but it may not last over time if the windshield is subjected to additional stress.

Replacement durability:

  • A new windshield guarantees better longevity and greater resistance to future impacts.

6. Impact on Security

Safety is a key factor when deciding whether to repair or replace a windshield. A cracked or poorly repaired windshield can compromise the structure of the vehicle in the event of an accident, reducing the effectiveness of airbags and increasing the risk of injury.

Repair safety:

  • If the impact is properly repaired, the windshield retains its protective capacity, but this remains less certain than a complete replacement.

Replacement safety:

  • The replacement ensures maximum safety, as the new windshield is designed to guarantee complete protection in the event of an impact or accident.

Conclusion

Choosing between repairing and replacing your windshield depends mainly on the extent of the damage and the location of the impact. While repair can be a quick and cost-effective solution for small impacts, replacement ensures greater safety and durability when the damage is more extensive.

At YES GLASS , we help you make the right choice and we support you every step of the way, whether it's repair or replacement. Contact us today for a free quote and fast intervention!

Back to blog